Review desolation-of-smaug-image

Published on January 4th, 2014 | by Allan Brown


The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Review


Movie Review: The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013)the-hobbit-the desolation of smaug film-poster. movie review world

Rating: 12A

Running Time: 161 mins

Director: Peter Jackson

Writers: Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Guillermo del Toro, J.R.R. Tolkien

Cast: Ian McKellen, Martin Freeman, Richard Armitage, ken Scott, Adam Brown, Orlando Bloom, James Nesbitt, Evangeline Lilly, Cate Blanchett, Luke Evans, Stephen Fry, Sylvester McCoy, Benedict Cumberbatch, Aiden Turner

Plot: Bilbo Baggins and the company of dwarves led by Gandalf the Grey, continue their quest to reclaim their homeland deep within the Lonely Mountain, from Smaug.


Movie Review World

With the mammoth character introductions and basic groundwork outlined in the first movie, the sequel to Peter Jacksons Hobbit trilogy moves forward quickly, as we continue to trail a Hobbit, a Wizard and a company of Dwaves on their quest to recover treasure, and reclaim their stolen kingdom of Erebor (The Lonely Mountain) from a rather large and un-welcomed tenant by the name of Smaug the magnificent.
thorin-oakenshield and the dwarves look on at the lonley mountain on the film the desolation of smaug.In keeping with the mythos of Middle Earth that Jackson has created over 5 films, there are many fan appeasing nods and associated links to LOTR throughout. These moments not only add an element of fun but also a satisfying (sometimes clumsy) sense of constancy.

These links include Howard Shore’s valiant return to Middle Earth, were he again not only provides the voice of the landscape but delivers some beautifully enchanting themes to an already multi layered backdrop.

Other familiar faces from LOTR include, an ostentatious return from Orlando Bloom reprising the role of everybody’s favourite Elven Prince, Legolas . Sauron to makes a brief and sinister return as he meets Gandalf in an unexpected face-off at Dol Guldur.

Peter Jackson has fine tuned his skills as a writer and found his middle earth groove again, after a shaky start

Of the new comers, Tauriel (Evangeline Lilly), a female Mirkwood elven guard who not only takes centre stage in many of the high octane battle sequences, but also plays Legolas’ love interest, although a certain Dwarf by the name of Fili’s also fights for her affections. Actor Luke Evans enters the fray as Bard the boatman, a man who is more than meets the eye and our company’s ticket into Laketown, where a shrewd Mayor played by Stephen Fry awaits them. Finally, the voice of Smaug the dragon, a deep, unsettling and rumbling tone required to pull off such huge character and central antagonist, so who? None other than Martin Freeman’s partner in crime in the BBCs Sherlock Holmes series, Mr Benedict Cumberbatch, that’s who.

bilbo baggins barrel sequence from the desolation of smaug. movie review worldMuch has been said about the slower and often stagnant pace of Peter Jackson’s initial return to Middle Earth in; The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (review). Some grumbled and continue too, that such a short and simple structured book should not and could not successfully be developed into a trilogy, whilst keeping the integrity of J.R.R. Tolkein’s vision intact. To paraphrase Bilbo Baggins, it would “Feel thin. Sort of stretched, like butter scraped over too much bread”. And at times, despite its valiant effort, rich characters, beautiful landscape and charm, that is often how An Unexpected Journey felt.

Tauriel, whose purpose at times feels like it exists purely to fill the void left by Arwen in LOTR.

With the Desolation of Smaug however, Jackson has ironed out most of the pacing issues and increased the adventure element. It would be more accurate to say Peter Jackson has fine tuned his skills as a writer and found his middle earth groove again, after a shaky start. From the word go, the adventure pulls you in, its gripping, it’s absorbing, it’s funny, it’s visually stunning and has some of the most complex set pieces (barrel sequence) in recent memory. This time Jackson also shows more restrain with CGI, mixing physical and prosthetic effects with computer generated imagery to gain a more balanced and weighted reality than before. Sure there are a few moments where the age old rule of less is more could have been applied, but compared to An Unexpected Journey, this is more than a step in the right direction.

tauriel and legolas-romance on moutainside in the-hobbit-the-desolation-of-smaugHowever, that is not to say The Desolation of Smaug isn’t without its issues. Despite it being a snappier paced narrative than its predecessor, there are a few too many subplots going on that act as nothing more than filler (Gandalf’s venture with Radagast to Dol Guldur). Jackson, who at times seems a slave to appeasing fans of the original trilogy by offering some kind of linkage between the two franchises, seems to duplicate scenes and subplots that have come before. Indeed that can be said of the half baked and completely unnecessary love story led by Tauriel, whose character was fully imagined by Jackson. Here Tauriel, whose purpose at times feels like it exists purely to fill the void left by Arwen in LOTR. So much so, that some of her scenes feel like they have been lifted straight out of the fellowship of the ring, the healing sequence in particular.

With fewer introductions than before, the desolation of Smaug reshuffles the pack focusing most of its character development on Thorin Oakenshield. While this is understandable, it sadly pushes Bilbo into the background where he remains for most of the film. His departure from centre stage is felt throughout as he was our way in to the story, our narrator, essentially us.

With that said. The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug is a rich and exhilarating 161 minute fantasy adventure that is a thrill ride from start to finish.

The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Review Allan Brown


Summary: Peter Jackson returns to Middle Earth back on form, tackling most of the issues from before, resulting in a more concise and satisfying film.


User Rating: 0 (0 votes)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About the Author

Despite my 9-5 being consumed by the daily duties of an Electrician, Movie Review World serves as a platform for me to share my thoughts, explorations and reflections on one of my biggest passions, film.

6 Responses to The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Review

  1. Mark Walker says:

    Just saw this last night Allan and I’d agree with your rating. It still had a few issues but otherwise a great adventure tale.

  2. Anastasia says:

    This film was so nearly perfect, I totally agree with your review. If only it hadn’t been so long and stretched out I would have enjoyed it completely. My attention definitely dropped out during the hammed up Gandalf subplot – we know what happens with Sauron, move on! And although I appreciate Jackson introducing a female character for what is otherwise a (very well made) sausage-fest, I wish it had been in a more original aspect than as the predictable love interest.
    I just wanted to witness Freeman and Cumberbatch being their awesome selves for longer.

    • Allan Brown says:

      The trilogy is most definitely getting stronger, I just wish it hadn’t been unnecessarily stretched out over three films, as that is were most of the problems lie, in pacing and sub-plots that act as nothing more than filler. Thanks for dropping by.

  3. Nostra says:

    Really enjoyed this movie and it was so much better than the first one. Just found your site through a comment you left on another blog and it looks good.

    • Allan Brown says:

      Yeh I agree, Desolation was a much tighter film than its predecessor, further tightening required but all in all a vast improvement. Cant wait for There And Back Again.

      Thanks for stopping by, I always appreciate new visitor and feedback. I also stopped by your site, impressed. Consider your blog followed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top ↑
  • Email Subscription

    Enter your email address to subscribe to Movie Review World and never miss another post.

  • Follow Me

  • Interviews

    Featuring Top 8/8 of Interviews


    Read more

  • Most Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

    Ken Roche on EIFF 2017: Fog In August Review (Nebel Im August)
    on The Iceman Review
    Jenny on EIFF 2015: Scottish Mussel Review
    Allan Brown on EIFF 2017: Romans Review
    Sharyl Lim on EIFF 2017: Romans Review
  • Hot Topics


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers:

Copy Protected by Chetan's WP-Copyprotect.